Sunday, March 30, 2014

Noah - A Review

I went and watched the movie Noah with my wife Bethany and younger son Michael yesterday. I had heard a number of different things about the movie, including a couple of interviews with the writer and director Darren Aronofsky. I knew the people of faith were divided in their expectations of the movie; but I went in with an open mind. Like most of us, I want to see movies that treat my faith with respect, and I want them to do well. Did I find that at the theater this time? Note: there will not be any spoilers in this blog. I will keep the discussion in general terms. If you wish to see the movie, you can continue reading without fear of me giving anything away. The short answer to the first part is, "Yes." I know this is going to produce some controversy. Now, I am not saying that I think the events of Noah's life looked anything like the movie depicts. In order to take a short story that occupies a mere 3 chapters in Genesis and turn it into a feature length movie, the movie's makers had to take great liberties with the story, and augment it with their own imaginations. I don't even agree with many of the choices they made - I would much rather have seen some things done differently. But those are creative differences. What matters to me the most is that the makers of the film did not choose to mock the story in any way. The entire tale is couched in concepts that are entirely consistent with the meaning and purpose of the Biblical story. Ideas such as fallen angels, miracles, evil, and sin are woven into the story without any sense of sarcasm. The depths of man's depravity are presented as a given and worthy of judgement. Noah's struggle with hearing from God and doing His will are struggles that every person of faith can identify with, even if his struggles are at a level that we will never experience. Several complaints have been leveled against the film by believers, and I want to address them briefly. First, it is said that God is never mentioned by name in the entire movie. I believe this charge to be unfair. True, the word "God" is never used in the movie; the filmmakers prefer the identifier "The Creator" when speaking of Him. But this is merely a semantic difference. Everyone who watched the movie knows exactly who they are speaking of, and there is nothing about The Creator that is in any way inconsistent with the nature and character of the God of the Bible. Just as the name of God never appears in the book of Esther, but there is no doubt who had it working behind the scenes, so it is with this movie. The Creator is the God of the Bible. Second, I have heard some complain that it has an underlying environmentalist message. The only possible source of this complaint is with Noah's struggle to understand if God intends for there to be men on the earth after the flood. But my reading of the opening verses of Genesis 6 gives me very much the impression that if it weren't for Noah, God would not have had any humans on the earth after the flood. The evil in men's hearts was too pervasive. Sure, it is possible to read an anti-human environmentalist message into Noah's struggles, but only if you read them into Genesis 6 as well. Finally, I can imagine some believers disturbed by the imagery of the creation story, which clearly (to me) represents an evolutionary perspective. Now, if you know me, you know that that isn't going to disturb me. But before you get too upset that the presentation doesn't take 6 literal days, let me ask you - does not the presentation clearly indicate that the creation process was the ongoing handiwork of The Creator? And think of the audience. Had the film makers opted for a 6 day narrative, they would have lost the ability to speak to the large audience that cannot accept such a time frame. We as believers are more forgiving, having been taught by our Lord to look at deeper things, and can look past the superficial time frame to rejoice at a telling of the beginning that acknowledges the greatness of the creative work. Rather than being disturbed by a secondary issue, we can worship the Creator while sitting in a movie theater eating popcorn. But what about the movie itself? Did I enjoy it? My honest answer is very mixed. I think the film making was spectacular. The acting was very good. Michael complained that it was "too fantasy" for a story that wasn't fantasy. Perhaps he is right. But the real reason I struggled to enjoy the movie is that it was too real. The story is not a child's Sunday School story, with animals walking calmly into a floating zoo so that God could save them "2 by 2". It is an adult's story, telling of the very real pain and conflict present in the Biblical story. Noah was a righteous man surrounded by horrific evil. He was asked by God to perform a super-human task, and to watch as everything he had ever known was destroyed. In the flood scene we hear the screams of people dying just outside the boat - do we think this wasn't the experience of Noah and his family? Remember, in the Biblical story, God Himself shut the door of the ark, presumably so that Noah and his family would be powerless to save even one other person. This is not a sweet story told at bedtime to help a child go to sleep; this is a story of tragedy and destruction, one that would give us nightmares if we ourselves had lived through it. Understanding the psychological trauma experienced by Noah and his family, it is no wonder that the first time we encounter Noah off of the ark he is drunk - the trauma may very well have haunted his sleep for the next 350 years. How is it possible to enjoy such a story? It isn't. But I believe that people of faith should see the movie for two reasons. The first is a very practical one. If we want Hollywood to choose to make movies that take our faith seriously, these movies must succeed when they are made. But the other in a reason of faith. The movie raises questions of belief and action, questions of justice and faith, questions of good and evil. Do you believe in a God who creates and destroys? Do you believe that men, while made in His image, are corrupt through and through? This movie will force you to confront that belief, and it will, if you allow it, let you leave with your faith not only intact, but strengthened as you see God triumph through the actions of imperfect, broken men and women. Men and women like you and I.


seniord said...

A different review, that I read, said that Noah attempted to kill his Grandchildren. If this is true, how does the make Noah a "just man and perfect in his generations"? If the above is true. This Noah is the typical caricature of the evil man of God. I would rather spend my money on a movie that casts faith in a better light. Such as, God Is Not Dead.

Dr. Don said...

Noah struggled with the question of whether God purpose was to cleanse the earth of human evil by cleansing it of humans. Ultimately, he makes the decision to allow his grandchildren to live.

The wonderful thing about America is that you can see both movies. I have not yet seen God Is Not Dead but I intend to.

Anonymous said...

I have not seen the movie but I agree that the trauma Noah experienced must have been epic. Thanks for challenging us to think about the points where we agree with the movie. Love the blog!!!